I need to start by saying that I love Dr WHO.
As a boy, I grew up with classic STAR TREK, Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea, Lost In Space, Marine Boy, Blake's 7, Thunderbirds, Stingray
and the Doctor. As a family we have as much as there is to have on DVD - with several more on pre-order, one adventure on Laserdisc (Terror Of The Zygons - cracking it is too), have dozens of autographs and have had the enjoyment of meeting personally a good number of Doctors and cast, at signing and memorabilia events. My son lives and breaths WHO.
When it came back...Ecclestone was excellent, Tennant made the role his own, and then came Matt Smith, and I was not so sure to begin with. When I saw his publicity photos I thought, 'this is just a boy really, how is he going to play a 900+ year old Timelord?'
The truth is...brilliantly. The chemistry between him and Karen Gillan is there in abundance. Just as it was between Ecclestone and Piper, and then Tennant and Piper. Just as it is, sadly, sorely missing between Gillan and Darvill.
Matt has proven himself well up to the huge role that is the Doctor with apparent ease. Very impressive indeed actually, for such a young man. His quirky 'sees everything through the eyes of a child' approach really works fantastically. The role is certainly in the hands of the right actor.
And the show is in the hands of the right producer in the Grand 'Moff' His first full season as show-runner was stunning. All the actors settled into their respective roles very quickly and season five, I am sure, will be remembered as a high point of the show.
As for season six. I am not enjoying it as much as I thought that I would, mainly for one reason...whilst Moffat/Smith's first season will be remembered for having everything balanced just right, I suspect that most folks will eventually look upon season six as having the balance slewed over too far into the setting up of things early, with the intention of partially paying them off at the close of the first half of the season...and then fully at the end of the season proper.
It was a brave move to open the series with a cliff hanger and then not really answer any question in the concluding part...only pile on more questions. Brave indeed. But I really think that it will come to be regarded as going a bit too far in that 'build the mystery' direction.
It's not that I am not enjoying it, but there should be at least some satisfying answers, even if each 'answer' only leads to two/three more perplexing questions.
That said, Smith continues to be excellent, Gillan continues to be an easy equal to Piper, Kingston just looks red hot and gorgeous in those jodhpurs and Darvill is...well, just...there. How many times will
- Spoiler:
we see Rory dead before they really finally pull the trigger on it and actually kill him, I mean, he's older than the Doctor...doesn't seem right somehow.
I am sure that when we get to see the whole pay-off, it will be spectacular and I will say "Oh yes, I can see why now" but just for right now, it is elluding me.